Reasonable adjustments for injured employees? Think broadly.

Under equal opportunity legislation, employers are required to make reasonable adjustments for employees with a disability so they can continue to perform the genuine and reasonable requirements of their position.

A recent decision of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal highlights the importance of taking a broad view about the reasonable adjustments that can be made to enable an employee with a disability to perform their role.

In particular, when determining the reasonable adjustments that can be made to an employee’s position, employers must consider whether the employee would be able to perform an adjusted position in other departments.

The Applicant was employed as a Customer Service Officer (CSO) in a call centre. She suffered neck and shoulder injuries due to alleged overuse of the telephone and subsequently lodged a workers’ compensation claim which was accepted.

After an extended period working modified duties, the employer terminated her employment due to her indefinite inability to perform the inherent requirements of her pre-injury position, and having decided that there were no reasonable adjustments that could be made. The Applicant claimed she had been discriminated against on grounds of disability.

The Tribunal found the employer had failed to make reasonable adjustments. The employer had focused too narrowly on reasonable adjustments that could be made to the Applicant’s pre-injury CSO position in the call centre. The employer failed to consider whether the Applicant could perform an adjusted CSO role in another department serviced by CSOs (and in which she had worked in the past) which involved less telephone use.

The Tribunal held that:

  • deciding what, if any, reasonable adjustments can be made requires an analysis of the requirements of the employment as a whole, and that analysis should not be too narrow; and
  • here, the role of CSO did not necessarily require answering phones full-time in the call centre. Not all CSOs worked in the call centre. Looking at the position as a whole, there were other areas in which the Applicant could work as a CSO with less telephone time.

The Applicant was awarded $3,325 in damages for economic loss (the Applicant found alternative employment within around six weeks of her dismissal), and $10,000 for hurt and distress.

The Tribunal noted that when considering whether adjustments are reasonable, an employer is entitled to consider the impact on efficiency and productivity, and customer service. Employers are not required to create a new job for a disabled employee, but they may be required to move staff around within a position to allow the disabled employee to undertake a high proportion of other tasks.

It is likely that both parties’ legal costs far exceeded the amounts awarded in this case. As such, the case serves as a timely reminder to consider, if possible, the early commercial resolution of disputes.

Butterworth v Independence Australia Services (Human Rights) [2015] VCAT 2056 (22 December 2015)


Emma Woolley

Partner & Head of Family Office Advisory

Karl Rozenbergs

Partner & Co-Lead, Health & Community

Ben Hamilton

Partner & Technology and Digital Economy Co-Lead

James Deady

Partner & Technology and Digital Economy Co-Lead

Eugene Chen

Partner & Head of China Practice

Oliver Jankowsky

Partner & Head of International Desks

John Bassilios

Partner & Fintech and Blockchain Lead

Matthew Curll

Partner & Insurance National Practice Leader

Melanie Smith

Director – Business Development, Marketing and Communications

Natalie Bannister

Partner & Commercial National Practice Leader

Nathan Kennedy

Partner, Head of Pro Bono & Community and ESG Co-Lead

Mark Dessi

Partner & Energy Co-Lead

Katie McKenzie

Director – People & Culture

James Bull

Special Counsel & Frank Lab Co-Lead

Melanie James

People & Culture Manager

Jacqui Barrett

Partner & Head of US Desk

Lauren Parrant

Senior People & Culture Advisor

Melinda Woledge

Marketing & Communications Manager

Jasmine Koh

Senior Associate & Frank Lab Co-Lead

Alison Choy Flannigan

Partner & Co-Lead, Health & Community

Jordon Lee


Geoff Benson


Meg Lee

Partner & ESG Co-Lead

John Gray

Partner, Technology & Digital Economy Co-Lead and NSW Government Co-Lead

Harvey Duckett


Luke Denham


Billie Kerkez

Manager – Smarter Recovery Solutions

Jemima Whiteman


Bradley White


Sarah Khan


Audrey Leahy

Special Counsel & Head of Irish Desk

Marie Mitilineos


Gloria Tam


Peter Jones

Senior Commercial Counsel

Eden Winokur

Partner & Head of Cyber

Sheldon Fu


Tamara Charlwood


James Pavlidis


Claire Bourke


Chloe Taylor


Silvana Brcina


Daphne Schilizzi


Andrew Banks


Isabella Urso


Jessica Liu


Amelia Spratt


Lisa Ziegert

Director – Client Solutions

David Cooper

Partner & Energy Co-Lead

Luke Raams


Emma McDonald


Carl Ayers


Maddison Reznik

Senior Associate & Trade Marks Attorney

Rebecca Dodd


Gretel Burns