Latest case updates for self-insurers – September 2026
Following a comprehensive review of cases across Australia, we have identified a selection that we regard as noteworthy. These cases exemplify key legal principles, serve as timely reminders of relevant principles and offer practical insights that can be applied in day-to-day professional practice.
Credibility counts: the importance of accurate histories in psychiatric injury claims
Jackson v VWA [2026] VCC 678 (20 May 2026)
Background
Ms Jackson brought a serious injury application in respect of a psychiatric injury she alleged she sustained after being sexually harassed by a co-worker. For the purposes of the originating motion, the Victorian WorkCover Authority, accepted that Ms Jackson had been subjected to inappropriate workplace conduct and had suffered some psychological upset. However, it argued that her injuries did not meet the test to be considered serious.
The court found that Ms Jackson:
falsely stated in an affidavit that she had not returned to work after ceasing with her employer;
failed to disclose subsequent employment with an aged care provider and FIFO cleaning work;
made false declarations in Certificates of Capacity stating that she had not worked during periods when she had in fact been working, for the purpose of continuing to receive weekly payments; and
failed to provide accurate work histories to treating and medico-legal practitioners.
The court concluded that Ms Jackson had given false evidence in affidavits, during oral evidence and in Certificates of Capacity. While several treating practitioners diagnosed post-traumatic stress disorder and supported a view that Ms Jackson had no work capacity, the court found those opinions were based on incomplete and inaccurate histories. In particular, the practitioners were unaware of significant periods of post-injury employment. As a result, the court attached limited weight to much of the psychiatric evidence relied upon by Ms Jackson.
Findings
The court ultimately refused the serious injury application, finding that Ms Jackson’s credibility had been so significantly undermined that it could not safely rely upon either her evidence or the medical opinions that depended upon the accuracy of the history she provided.
The court reiterated that, in psychiatric injury cases, expert opinion is often only as reliable as the factual history on which it is based.
Key takeaways
The decision is a strong reminder that in psychiatric injury claims, credibility can be determinative, particularly where medical opinions are largely based on the worker's self-reported history, even where it is accepted that workplace misconduct occurred.
The case also highlights the importance of a complete factual investigation, including reviewing employment records, payroll information and Certificates of Capacity for inconsistencies.
Temporary aggravation falls short of serious injury threshold
Shea v Victorian WorkCover Authority [2026] VCC 10
Background
Mr Shea, a youth justice worker, brought a serious injury application after allegedly sustaining a right‑knee injury during an incident at work on 23 October 2020. He sought to pursue common law damages for pain and suffering and loss of earning capacity, relying on clause (a) of the definition of ‘serious injury’ - permanent serious impairment or loss of a body function.
Mr Shea had a history of right knee problems, including previous knee surgery. The case centred on whether the workplace incident caused a permanent and serious impairment of his knee, including whether it aggravated any underlying degenerative pathology.
To succeed, Mr Shea needed to show that the incident caused a material, permanent and significant worsening of the underlying condition, resulting in enduring functional loss and pain consequences that met the serious injury threshold.
Findings
The court was not satisfied this burden was met.
Orthopaedic evidence indicated that Mr Shea’s symptoms were largely consistent with the natural progression of degenerative change rather than a traumatic aggravation.
His functional presentation, including continued work capacity, fluctuating symptoms and periods of improvement, did not align with the level of impairment required to establish serious injury.
After reviewing the medical evidence, employment history and Mr Shea’s reported consequences, the court concluded that the claimed impairment and its consequences did not reach the level of severity or permanence required for a serious injury finding.
The court ultimately found that any aggravation was modest and temporary, falling well short of a permanent serious impairment and the alleged loss of earning capacity was not supported by objective evidence.
Key takeaways
This decision reinforces that claims involving pre-existing pathology require careful scrutiny. To succeed, a worker must establish a clear, incident-related deterioration that is both significant and permanent, supported by persuasive medical evidence.
The mere existence of ongoing symptoms or degenerative pathology is not enough. Where the evidence is more consistent with the natural progression of an underlying condition, or where symptoms fluctuate over time, establishing a serious injury may prove difficult. Consistent, objective medical evidence remains critical.
Contractor, not worker: carpet installer found to be operating an independent business
Bostanabad v Carpet Call Vic Pty Ltd [2026] VMC 1
Background
The Magistrates’ Court of Victoria was required to determine whether Mr Bostanabad, a carpet installer, was a deemed worker for Carpet Call under the Workplace Injury Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2013 (WIRCA).
It was accepted that Mr Bostanabad was not a ‘worker’ under the primary definition in the WIRCA. However, the court was asked to deliver a preliminary ruling on whether Mr Bostanabad was a deemed worker by virtue of the operation of clause 9 of Schedule 1. This required consideration as to whether Mr Bostanabad was carrying on an ‘independent trade or businesses.’
Findings
The court noted that this was, in many ways, an unusual case. It concluded that Mr Bostanabad was not a witness of credit and his evidence was unreliable, although he made numerous concessions against his interest.
However, the court was required to make a determination based on an objective evaluation of the evidence as a whole. This involved asking whether Mr Bostanabad’s trade or business was subject to control or subordination by Carpet Call, and whether the trade or business depended on Carpet Call for its existence.
The court ultimately found that Mr Bostanabad’s trade or business was not subject to control or subordination by Carpet Call, after making the following findings:
Mr Bostanabad entered into the agreement freely and without any element of subordination or pressure on the part of Carpet Call;
He evidence was that he provided his services to Carpet Call exclusively because the business arrangement was favourable to him;
the scope of work was broad, and there was little control or direction imposed by Carpet Call, with Mr Bostanabad able to independently make decisions about transportation, preparation of floor covering and supply of ancillary materials;
other than a broad requirement that the work comply with ‘industry best practice’ and consumer standards, Carpet Call did not require Mr Bostanabad to follow any particular system of work or process for installing carpets, and imposed no training requirements;
Mr Bostanabad was responsible for dealing with customer complaints;
Carpet Call did not require Mr Bostanabad to operate through a particular type of legal entity;
Mr Bostanabad was free to hire and fire employees at his sole discretion to perform work with him or for him on jobs assigned by Carpet Call;
Mr Bostanabad was free to accept or reject work offered to him, subject to providing ten days’ notice of his unavailability, and was in no way constrained in the hours he chose to work; and
Mr Bostanabad did not wear a uniform on behalf of Carpet Call, drive a vehicle with its logo or otherwise present to the public as a representative of Carpet Call.
The court also concluded that Mr Bostanabad trade or business did not depend on Carpet Call for its existence. It ultimately found that, in providing services to Carpet Call, Mr Bostanabad was carrying out an independent trade or business and was therefore not deemed to be a worker.
Key takeaways
The court's analysis reinforces that whether a person is a deemed worker under the WIRCA turns on an objective assessment of the entirety of the relationship, rather than any single factor.
Importantly, working exclusively for one principal does not necessarily prevent a contractor from operating an independent trade or business. The key inquiry remains whether the contractor is genuinely operating their own enterprise, free from significant control or subordination, and whether that enterprise is capable of existing independently of the principal.
For self-insurers, the decision highlights the importance of examining the practical realities of the relationship rather than relying solely on contractual labels.
Fresh eyes required: Supreme Court orders referral to a new Medical Panel
Foley v SILA Transport Pty Ltd [2026] VSC 14
Background
The Supreme Court of Victoria recently considered whether a matter should be remitted to the same or a differently constituted medical panel after an earlier opinion was quashed for jurisdictional error.
Mr Foley worked for SILA Transport as an exhaust fabricator between 2009 and 2018. He lodged a claim in June 2018 and subsequently sought impairment benefits. In October 2021, the insurer issued a notice of entitlement accepting liability for a cervical spine injury but assessing Mr Foley as having sustained a 0 per cent whole person impairment.
Mr Foley disputed the assessment, resulting in a referral to a medical panel in March 2022. The referral was later suspended while Mr Foley underwent further treatment.
In August 2024, Mr Foley’s neurosurgeon considered his condition stable, and the insurer made a second referral to the medical panel. The panel sought clarification as to whether the original 2022 referral should be reactivated or replaced by the 2024 referral. The insurer instructed the panel to reactivate the 2022 referral and cancel the 2024 referral.
In its opinion dated 23 December 2024, the medical panel stated that it had based its reasons on the material provided in Enclosure A, which compromised the documents in the 2022 referral. This means it had not considered the additional documents included in the 2024 referral. Despite being tasked with providing an impairment assessment, the panel ultimately provided an opinion that there was no clinical evidence of ongoing injury.
The parties subsequently agreed, by joint memorandum, that Mr Foley had been denied procedural fairness. An order of certiorari was made quashing the medical panel's opinion. The remaining issue for determination was whether the matter should be remitted to the same or a differently constituted medical panel.
Findings
The court ultimately held that the matter should be remitted to a differently constituted medical panel.
The court emphasised that there is no universal rule governing remittal decisions. Whether a matter should be returned to the same decision-maker depends on the circumstances of the case. A party seeking referral to a different panel must establish a ‘good reason’ based on established principles. This may include circumstances where remittal to the same decision-maker would be unfair, create an appearance of unfairness, or create a risk that the original decision-maker may attempt to ‘patch up’ defective reasoning.
Although the court was not required to assess the clinical significance of the omitted medical material, it considered the potential importance of that material to the central issues in dispute to be a significant factor.
The court also noted the medical panel had expressed strong views that Mr Foley had no ongoing cervical spine injury, despite the defendant having accepted the existence of such an injury. The issue was not whether the panel's conclusion was medically correct, but whether the strength of the views expressed could create actual or perceived unfairness if the matter were remitted to the same panel.
While the court acknowledged that remittal to the same panel could provide efficiencies due to its familiarity with the matter, those efficiencies were outweighed by the perception of unfairness.
Key takeaways
Where a medical panel opinion is quashed, whether the matter should be remitted to the same or a differently constituted panel will depend on the circumstances of the case. There is no universal rule, and a party seeking a different panel must demonstrate a ‘good reason’ based on established legal principles.
The decision also demonstrates that potential unfairness, including the strength of views previously expressed and the significance of material not considered, may outweigh the efficiencies of returning a matter to the original panel.
Continue building your self-insurer knowledge with our A–Z of workers’ compensation webinar series and Season 3 of our Self-insurers in Australia podcast.
You can catch up on our Victorian webinar series on demand or follow the New South Wales series as it continues. You can also tune into the first two-episodes of our new podcast season, with more practical insights for self-insurers coming soon.
Register to access the webinars: Victoria | New South Wales
Listen to season 3 of our Self-Insurers in Australia podcast.
For a practical comparison of workers’ compensation schemes across jurisdictions, see our national comparative table.
Contact
