Federal Court clarifies legal professional privilege and waiver in safe harbour advice
A recent Federal Court decision has clarified when directors can claim legal professional privilege over safe harbour advice and how that privilege can be lost through disclosure.
In McCabe v Mosaic Brands Limited, in the matter of Mosaic Brands Limited (In Liquidation) (Receivers and Managers Appointed) [2026] FCA 1569, delivered on 22 October 2026, the court considered two important questions for directors, restructuring advisors and insolvency practitioners:
- Did privilege in safe harbour advice belong to the directors alone, or was it shared with the companies?
- Had the directors waived that privilege by providing material to administrators or recording advice in board minutes?
The court found that the directors held privilege to the exclusion of the companies. However, that protection was lost through particular disclosures and the recording of advice in board minutes.
The decision raises a key practical question that we often discuss with directors in setting up a safe harbour engagement: how is the engagement to be structured to protect claims for privilege over the associated legal advice?
Key takeaways
Directors, advisors and insolvency practitioners should note:
Directors may hold privilege in safe harbour advice to the exclusion of the company. Who retained the advisor, the work that was undertaken and whose interests it served remain important considerations. Payment by the company is not determinative.
Privilege can be waived if advice is disclosed in a way that is inconsistent with maintaining the necessary confidentiality. The intended use of the material matters.
Involving employees in obtaining advice did not destroy confidentiality in this case. However, recording the substance of the directors’ advice in company board minutes waived privilege.
Former directors’ interests require separate consideration. The court qualified its finding about disclosure to administrators because there was no evidence that one former director had joined in that disclosure.
Directors should maintain proper records of restructuring decisions while keeping confidential legal advice about their personal protection separate.
How advice is communicated and recorded matters. Directors should consider who attends meetings, how discussions are minuted and where advice is stored. Sending advice to the company email addresses, or including it in company books and records, may create complexity when establishing privilege.
Background: Mosaic’s safe harbour advice
Mosaic Brands and its related companies operated fashion brands including Rivers, Millers, Noni B, Katies and Rockmans. Administrators were appointed in October 2024 and became general purpose liquidators in July 2025. Special purpose liquidators were appointed in December 2025 to undertake particular investigations.
The directors had obtained safe harbour advice from Hamilton Locke starting in March 2020. Deloitte was engaged to assist. There was no written retainer for Hamilton Locke’s safe harbour advice, and Deloitte’s engagement contained inconsistent descriptions of the client and the purpose of its work.
In December 2024, the directors supplied the administrators with a timeline, memorandum and linked documents explaining their reliance on safe harbour. The covering email sought to preserve privilege and asked that the documents not be shared, except with the administrators’ legal advisors, without consent.
The special purpose liquidators subsequently sought directions permitting inspection and use of documents over which the directors claimed exclusive privilege. The court first addressed ownership and waiver, leaving questions about sample document categories for separate determination if necessary.
Federal Court decision: who held privilege and when was it waived?
The court considered several questions about the ownership, confidentiality and waiver of legal professional privilege.
Did the directors hold privilege to the exclusion of the companies?
Yes. The court found that the directors held exclusive privilege over the safe harbour advice considered by the case.
The court inferred a retainer with the directors alone from the contemporaneous communications, their reasonable understanding and the work undertaken. Hamilton Locke’s continued representation of the directors after administration was also significant. The absence of a written retainer did not defeat the claim.
The court distinguished the restructuring course pursued for the company’s benefit from advice about the directors’ personal statutory protection. It did not accept that the company’s interest in a successful restructure necessarily gave it an interest in that advice.
This does not mean all restructuring advice belongs exclusively to directors. In Re Atlas Construction Group Pty Ltd (in liquidation), a retainer expressed in directors’ names did not establish privilege against the company’s liquidator where the surrounding evidence supported a joint retainer. A carefully drafted engagement should reflect the work actually undertaken.
The court also did not finally resolve privilege across Deloitte’s work. The relevant question was whether its communications assisted Hamilton Locke to provide advice to the directors. That required further consideration of the documents.
Did involving company employees affect confidentiality?
No. The court found that involving company employees in obtaining advice did not destroy confidentiality or waive privilege on these facts.
Senior employees, and sometimes their assistants, helped obtain information needed for the advice. The directors did not have ready access to all that information. Sharing advice and drafts with those assisting them did not destroy confidentiality or waive privilege against the companies employing those staff.
The finding does not authorise unrestricted circulation. It recognises that obtaining advice can require assistance from people who hold the relevant financial and operational information.
Were the directors compelled to provide the privileged material to the administrators?
No. The court found that the administrators’ requests did not compel the directors to provide the privileged material they disclosed. The directors relied on the administrators’ requests and the consequences of non-compliance under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), including s 588GB. That section can prevent a person later relying on company books or information to support safe harbour where specified disclosure obligations have not been met, subject to exceptions.
The court examined the requests closely. The October notice sought company books. Most categories in the December letter sought company communications and advice; the remaining category sought a summary of the directors’ reliance on safe harbour, not their underlying privileged documents.
The December letter was not itself a compulsory process merely because it referred to s 588GB. The directors elected to provide more extensive material.
The decision should not be read as permitting directors to disregard statutory requests or withhold company records generally.
Did reserving privilege prevent waiver?
No. The court found that the directors’ express reservation of privilege did not prevent waiver through their disclosure of the material. Applying Mann v Carnell, the court considered whether the deliberate disclosure was inconsistent with maintaining the protected confidentiality. The directors’ stated intention not to waive privilege was not decisive.
The material enabled the administrators to assess the directors’ reliance on safe harbour against possible future insolvent trading claims. Describing its provision as inadvertent did not alter the intentional nature of the disclosure.
The waiver was not limited to the administrators in that capacity. They subsequently became liquidators, and the special purpose liquidators stood in their shoes for the particular investigative role. The court found that the relevant waiver extended beyond those officeholders.
Did the former director’s position affect the waiver of privilege?
Yes. The court found that the former director’s position affected the waiver arising from disclosure to the administrators. There was no evidence that Sue Morphet, who resigned on 21 June 2021, joined in that disclosure. The court treated the retainer as benefiting directors from time to time and found no waiver through that disclosure insofar as the material concerned events on or before her resignation.
The qualification concerned the events addressed by the material, not simply its creation date. A later memorandum describing an earlier period therefore requires closer review. However, the separate finding about board minutes must also be considered.
Did recording legal advice in board minutes waive privilege?
Yes. The court found that recording the substance of the directors’ legal advice in company board minutes waived their exclusive privilege over that advice. The court distinguished the company’s confidentiality in its minutes from the directors’ personal confidentiality in their legal advice. The directors could have recorded only that advice was discussed, or maintained a separate confidential document, rather than including its substance in company minutes.
On the assumption that all relevant directors approved the minutes, the court found no equivalent difficulty about their concurrence in that waiver. The former director qualification did not therefore establish that all earlier material remained protected.
Separately, the liquidators did not prove waiver from disclosure of minutes to BDO. The evidence did not establish what had been sent or whether it included safe harbour advice. This was not a general ruling that disclosure to auditors preserves privilege.
Practical implications for directors and insolvency practitioners
Maintain restructuring records while protecting legal advice
The response should not be to stop documenting the restructure. Section 588GA(3) places an evidential burden on a person relying on safe harbour. ASIC’s Regulatory Guide 217 encourages directors to document decisions and retain evidence of the courses of action developed, implemented and monitored.
Directors and advisors should distinguish the company’s factual and operational record from legal advice about the directors’ personal position. Forecasts, assumptions, options considered, decisions and progress against the plan should remain properly documented.
The substance of personal legal advice should be separately managed in discussions and communications between appropriate individuals to protect privilege.
However, this distinction does not guarantee privilege. Separate folders or labels do not establish the dominant purpose for which a communication was created. Nor should existing minutes be altered or records destroyed in an attempt to restore confidentiality already lost.
Review disclosures carefully to avoid waiving privilege
Before providing a narrative explaining or justifying reliance on safe harbour, directors should assess what it reveals about the advice and the documents it attaches or makes available by link. A limited covering email may accompany a much broader disclosure.
The review should identify who holds the privilege, whose authority is needed, the purpose for which the recipient will use the material and whether further disclosure or use in proceedings is contemplated. Current board membership alone may not answer the authority question.
An express agreement restricting use and further disclosure may assist but should not be treated as an assurance that privilege will survive. As Asahi Holdings (Australia) Pty Ltd v Pacific Equity Partners Pty Limited (No 2) demonstrates, the assessment remains sensitive to the purpose and circumstances of disclosure.
Assess privilege claims based on each document’s content and history
For administrators and liquidators, the decision supports a document-specific approach. Company advice, directors’ exclusive advice, underlying company records and material affected by a particular waiver should not be treated as one category.
A review should consider the events addressed, the directors entitled to the advice and any earlier disclosure, including through approved minutes. Possession of a document does not itself resolve privilege, while a general assertion of directors’ privilege does not establish the claim.
The decision provides useful guidance on the distinction between obtaining privileged advice and preserving it. Directors should maintain a reliable record of their restructuring efforts, while making deliberate and informed decisions about disclosure of their personal legal advice. For insolvency practitioners, the scope of any privilege or waiver remains a matter to establish, not assume.
How we can help
Hall & Wilcox’s restructuring and insolvency lawyers regularly assist directors, companies and insolvency practitioners with safe harbour arrangements, legal professional privilege and issues arising during restructuring and insolvency.
If you would like to understand how the decision may affect your circumstances, contact our team.
Contact









