Federal Court clarifies legal professional privilege and waiver in safe harbour advice

Insights12 Nov 2026

A recent Federal Court decision has clarified when directors can claim legal professional privilege over safe harbour advice and how that privilege can be lost through disclosure. 

In McCabe v Mosaic Brands Limited, in the matter of Mosaic Brands Limited (In Liquidation) (Receivers and Managers Appointed) [2026] FCA 1569, delivered on 22 October 2026, the court considered two important questions for directors, restructuring advisors and insolvency practitioners:

  • Did privilege in safe harbour advice belong to the directors alone, or was it shared with the companies?
  • Had the directors waived that privilege by providing material to administrators or recording advice in board minutes?

The court found that the directors held privilege to the exclusion of the companies. However, that protection was lost through particular disclosures and the recording of advice in board minutes. 

The decision raises a key practical question that we often discuss with directors in setting up a safe harbour engagement: how is the engagement to be structured to protect claims for privilege over the associated legal advice?

Key takeaways

Directors, advisors and insolvency practitioners should note: 

  • Directors may hold privilege in safe harbour advice to the exclusion of the company. Who retained the advisor, the work that was undertaken and whose interests it served remain important considerations. Payment by the company is not determinative.

  • Privilege can be waived if advice is disclosed in a way that is inconsistent with maintaining the necessary confidentiality. The intended use of the material matters.

  • Involving employees in obtaining advice did not destroy confidentiality in this case. However, recording the substance of the directors’ advice in company board minutes waived privilege. 

  • Former directors’ interests require separate consideration. The court qualified its finding about disclosure to administrators because there was no evidence that one former director had joined in that disclosure.

  • Directors should maintain proper records of restructuring decisions while keeping confidential legal advice about their personal protection separate.

  • How advice is communicated and recorded matters. Directors should consider who attends meetings, how discussions are minuted and where advice is stored. Sending advice to the company email addresses, or including it in company books and records, may create complexity when establishing privilege.

Background: Mosaic’s safe harbour advice

Federal Court decision: who held privilege and when was it waived?

Practical implications for directors and insolvency practitioners

How we can help

Hall & Wilcox’s restructuring and insolvency lawyers regularly assist directors, companies and insolvency practitioners with safe harbour arrangements, legal professional privilege and issues arising during restructuring and insolvency.

If you would like to understand how the decision may affect your circumstances, contact our team. 

Contact

Hall & Wilcox acknowledges the Traditional Custodians of the land, sea and waters on which we work, live and engage. We pay our respects to Elders past, present and emerging.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of service apply.