Disability Claims


Related expertise

We have demonstrated experience and capability advising on litigated and non-litigated disability claims and policy disputes.

Our team has acted for a number of life and disability insurers, underwriting agencies and trustees of superannuation funds in the areas of:

  • Total and Permanent Disability (TPD) & Total and Temporary Disability (TTD)
  • Trauma
  • Income protection
  • Group life
  • Critical illness
  • Death
  • Personal accident and sickness
  • Travel insurance.


Our policy interpretation advice is backed by an excellent knowledge of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth), including drafting entire policies and PDS statements for clients.

Our team’s focus is on providing high quality legal services through fully understanding developments in the evolving case law, responding to our insurer’s needs and providing reasoned strategic recommendations. We offer a unique combination of technical expertise, regulatory insight and commercial understanding through the multi-faceted experience of our team.


Our team’s experience includes:

  • Investigating and advising on the legitimacy of contentious TPD and TTD claims, and defending and negotiating resolution of litigated TPD claims including:
    • A plaintiff under a group policy who claimed a disc bulge was a new back injury rendering the plaintiff TPD based on the initial diagnosis, but our investigations revealed a long term degenerative condition and previous back injury triggering relevant exclusions.
    • A plaintiff who allegedly suffered post-traumatic stress disorder and brought proceedings following a TPD claim declinature under a corporate travel policy. We successfully argued that the plaintiff did not suffer a diagnosable psychological injury and the injury was not in direct connection with a ‘catastrophic/critical event’ to trigger the relevant insuring clause.
    • Acting for the trustee of an industry super fund in relation to litigated TPD claims by members of group life and income protection policies and successfully securing favourable indemnities for the client.
    • Defending a TPD claim following the insurer’s decision to cease paying a permanent disability pension on the basis that the member’s medical condition had changed such that she no longer met the definition of being TPD. The evidence indicated that that member was a malingerer and expert evidence established that her reported symptoms were inconsistent with the objective medical evidence.
  • Investigating and advising on the legitimacy of contentious death claims including negotiation of an early ‘walk away’ settlement in a death claim involving a claimant contracting a flesh-eating disease after suffering a laceration. The key issue was whether the cause of death arose from a pre-existing condition or a ‘sickness’ which was excluded by the terms of cover.
  • Advising on policy response and causation issues (for example, whether it was an ‘event’ that ‘caused’ a heart attack while on an airplane), including pre-existing conditions and the application of section 47 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984.
  • Drafting a life insurer’s AFCA submissions for disputes relating to such issues as:
    • Pre-existing conditions and the application of s47 of the ICA
    • Classification of an injury as temporary/permanent
    • The duration of the policy benefit/weekly benefit entitlement
    • Leading an interactive Case Study presentation with the claims team of that insurer to provide insight on AFCA’s approach towards section 47 and to better inform the claims team when making claim decisions and drafting their own submissions.
  • Advising on non-disclosure and misrepresentation issues (innocent and fraudulent), including providing advice regarding remedies available under section 29 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984.
  • Advising on rights and issues relating to subrogated recovery for the insurer in the event the plaintiff brings a third party claim.
  • Preparing submissions to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA), and previously to the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS), in relation to TPD and income protection claims.

In conjunction with the above, we have a market leading, national personal injury practice which brings with it significant unparalleled depth, expertise and insight in relation to analysing, and approaching the defence of, the most complex of causation and medical issues directly relevant to life insurance claim issues. This extends to evolving claim areas such as mental health claims.

Key contacts

Matthew Curll


Co-Head of Financial Services & Insurance

Matthew Curll is one of the top ‘go-to’ people for Australian insurance law matters – both coverage and defence....

Ahranee advises insurers and corporates in the defence of public and product liability claims, both personal injury and property...

Zoe is a specialist insurance lawyer who manages complex and varied matters for a number of leading corporate insurers...

Tina has broad general insurance experience in defending personal injury claims on behalf of domestic and international insurers.

Mitch is an experienced insurance and litigation lawyer who has defended claims on behalf of insurer and private clients...

Related thinking

Insurance| 14 Oct 2021

Subrogated recoveries – think twice before agreeing a global settlement!

The Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia has handed down its decision following the appeal of Technology Swiss Pty Ltd v AAI Limited t/as Vero Insurance.

Insurance| 13 Oct 2021

COVID-19 BI test case: Round 2 goes to the insurers

Federal Court Justice Jane Jagot delivered a judgment in the second COVID-19 business interruption test case which was overwhelmingly in favour of the participating insurers.

Insurance| 27 Sep 2021

Hawking: ASIC lands its final guidance for the sale of financial products

ASIC has released its final guidance on the new hawking regime that commences on 5 October 2021.

Insurance| 23 Sep 2021

Financial Services in Focus – Issue 58

In this edition, we consider the final breach reporting regulatory guide, electronic execution and virtual meetings legislation, judicial commentary in relation to an AFS licensee’s supervisory arrangements, and much more.